John's Story

Catherine (Haliburton- Nealings) McCaskie
of Balmain Sydney NSW

Australian
Flag

Australian Flag

The following information was provided by Australian McCaskie descendants, who, like me, are very proud of their hard-working ancestors and their success in life.

Jack Brown's mother, Magdalena Gunther Brown who died 1984, aged 84 and her sister Daisy Gunther Beattie who died October 2000 aged 99 had provided a great fund of data on the Sydney McCaskies. They were grandchildren of John and Catherine

Monica Schladetsch's great great grandparents were John and Catherine. Her entry into my Guestbook on 16th January 2002 explains how proud we all are of our ancestors.  

Catherine's Story
Nealings,Nillans,Neilings,Neilans,Neillings and Nealings:
various spellings on different records

Bronte House

Catherine was born on 30 Apr 1828 in Cupar, County Fife, Scotland. Her father is unknown and her mother's name was Catherine Haliburton. She was raised by Thomas Nealings and his wife Elizabeth Johnstone. Catherine died on 14 Feb 1911 at her home in Crescent St., Balmain.
Catherine arrived on the "Canton" 12/6/1848, from Scotland.
The ship sailed from Cork.

Links to Australian Founding Fathers

Rev Dunmore Lang & Robert Lowe


Catherine Haliburton-Nealings story is a bit involved but very interesting. There were two Catherine Haliburtons involved - Catherine Haliburton the mother whom I will call No. 1 and her daughter Catherine Haliburton who marries John McCaskie, I will call No. 2.            

Catherine No 1 was born 24/7/1800 Newburgh, Fife, Scotland. Her parents were David Haliburton and Janet Laurence and they married 29/9/1794.
Catherine No.1 (unmarried) had a daughter on 30/4/1828 in Cupar, Fife, Scotland and she named her Catherine Haliburton (No 2). On 3/11/1828 Catherine No. 1 married Thomas Nealings and Catherine No 2 becomes known as Catherine Haliburton Nealings.      
No trace of Catherine No. 1 exists after that so I can only assume that she died, because Thomas Nealings married Elizabeth Johnston on 18/5/1832. The fact that Catherine No 2 was brought up by Thomas Nealings and Elizabeth Johnstone is aided by the fact that Catherine No 2 named her first daughter, Elizabeth Johnstone  McCaskie after her step mother. She also named one of her sons William Nealings McCaskie after her stepfather.                                                         
Although neither Thomas nor Elizabeth were Catherine's natural parents, they must have had a close bonding because they and their three boys followed Catherine out to Australia in about 1849/50. They lived at 26 Crescent St, Balmain, and one son William died there in 1907. John McCaskie lived in the same street. Thomas Nealings died at 865 George Street, South Sydney on 28 July 1883 and John McCaskie owned a fruit and vegetable shop at the same address. This suggests that there were strong on-going connections between the two families. There is also another connection - in 1873 John McCaskie owned a dairy at 84 Market St Sydney, and in 1878 Elizabeth Nealings died at Market St).                                          
Catherine's life continues to be interesting. She came to Australia with other Scottish emigrants under the immigration scheme promoted by Reverend Dunmore Lang. She was engaged by Mrs. Lowe, to be a personal maid and taken out to Bronte "far in the bush."  Read "The Greatest Story Never Told" written by her Granddaughter Elizabeth Beattie which includes extracts of Catherine's reminiscences.                                                                                                        
Her immigration shipping record shows that she could read and write, was Presbyterian, aged 20 years. Her occupation was a nursemaid, Her native place was Edinburgh, Scotland.
Catherine met John whilst they were both working for the Lowes at Bronte House. John was the Head Groomsman there.     
Catherine married John McCaskie on 24/9/1850 (York St Chapel, Sydney) and they went to the Californian gold rush in about 1851. Their first child, Elizabeth was born on board the vessel "John Calvin" as it was entering San Francisco Harbour, in May 1851. They returned to Sydney in 1857 and lived in Balmain for the rest of their lives.
Catherine was a Milliner and ran a business called The Fancy Bazaar from 837 George St., Sydney. Catherine and John McCaskie owned several other businesses and properties, see notes on John McCaskie.When Catherine died aged 83 in 1911 and a widow, she left a considerable estate.                                                                                 
THE GREATEST STORY NEVER TOLD 
Extracts of her reminiscences in an early edition of the Sydney Morning Herald
I was engaged on the emigrant ship by Mrs. Lowe, & taken out to Bronte far in the bush.

One day after I had been six months as personal maid, Mrs. Lowe said they were going to fine the Master for feeding his servants badly - I was to give witness to the contrary.

I went to the court in the Barouche, and was proud to sit next to Mrs. Lowe in her beautiful silk dress and elegant cloak.

My mistress was well known to all the gentleman of the court, and when we walked in everyone was very polite to her, but when she bade me step forward and said    "this is proof of how I feed my people" and my cheeks got red with shyness to be looked at by so many gentlemen, there was a cheer in the court and Mrs. Lowe was congratulated upon the care she took of her domestics
She bought me a new bonnet as a reward for behaving as she wished.  But if I was well fed as a free servant there were many who had no sugar, fresh meat, milk or fresh vegetables.
My heart aches now, even as an old woman, to think what privations those poor assigned servants had to undergo also their wives and families in those "Bad" old days, that seems now so long ago.
A dinner party at Bronte was a great event, though no ladies were present, partly because it was difficult to access and the gentlemen attending rode their own horses.  Dinner was at five o'clock and many of the guests left before darkness set in.
The topic of the day was "Responsible Government", Mrs. Lowe who was the only lady present, expressed her opinion in a way that few woman were able to at that time.
           
It was the time that everything was served at the table, Mr. Lowe would carve the home grown saddle of mutton, while his wife carved a fine turkey also grown on the estate.
My mistress looked quite regal in a trained velvet gown of deep sea green or black. I wore lilac and white and hovered around to see that everything came in properly, being called only by my surname as if I were the housekeeper   

Neallings couple

Very old photo of Catherine's step-parents
Thomas & Elizabeth Nealings both born about 1800

Communion Cards
for the Neallings
in 1850

Cards from the United Presbyterian Church, South College St Edinburgh, near the University in the Old Toun.

The former United Presbyterian Church, South College St Edinburgh


They lived at  2 St James Place, Edinburgh, EH1 right in the centre of town just off Princes St the main thoroughfare

The University of Edinburgh e-Science Institute is a sympathetic conversion of a former United Presbyterian Church which closed in 1961. It retains its original architectural features including stained glass windows and is now used as a first class conference and training facility with comprehensive audio-visual systems, and provides disabled access and induction loop system for the hearing impaired.

Situated in the historic Grassmarket of old Edinburgh, the Apex International Hotel was converted from former Heriot Watt University premises and provides a wonderful view of Edinburgh Castle

John's Story

Australian Picture Gallery

Australian Pictures

Bronte House

If after surfing the net the bottom Index Bar for this website is missing - take a note of this page -
then delete the bit after "forward slash" in the address bar of your browser - this will get the Index Bar back